The best toaster oven for 2021 – CNET [CNET]
For generations, the toaster oven has been a trusty, crusty countertop companion for toasting and baking, an appliance that also doubles as a second, smaller oven that boasts faster heating (and reheating) times than your main one.
But if you’re here to find the best toaster oven, the one that you must buy immediately with one click, well… I’m sorry to say I’ve got some disappointing news for you. Toaster ovens are, in my humble opinion, thoroughly overrated.
Maybe that’s a difficult truth to hear. The problem is that most food you’d want to toast, like bread or bagels, would be better off in a standard toaster, and most food you’d want to bake would turn out better sitting on an oven rack in your traditional oven, where it’ll benefit from a stronger set of heating elements. Either way, you’re compromising from the get-go. And good luck cooking a roast or other complicated and time-intensive foods in a countertop toaster oven, even if they do have the right temperature range.
Most toaster ovens are bulky as hell, too — and thanks to the rise of kitchen-friendly smart displays, food processors, Instant Pots, sous vide cookers, and the like, the chances are good that you’ve got a better way to put that precious counter space to use.
Read more: Top bread machines for home bakers
Still, maybe you don’t have a conventional oven and need a countertop toaster oven — or maybe you just want one, dammit. I get it! Despite my misgivings, there’s still a lot to like about the things. This is a much-beloved kitchen appliance we’re talking about, and my toasty hot take is probably a minority report.
But splurging doesn’t always make sense. Do you really need to add in modern luxuries like bar code scanners, built-in food cameras and smart cooking assistance? Techie toaster ovens from names such as Tovala, June and Brava can cost anywhere from $300 to $995, but most of the extras found in a mini smart oven are above and beyond what an average kitchen needs.
More reasonable are “upgrade pick” toaster ovens such as the fun, well-calibrated Panasonic FlashXpress, or a sturdy stalwart like the Breville Smart Oven, both of which we reviewed — and loved — a few years ago. But at $127 and $299 respectively, those models, too, are outside the mainstream in a world where a regular toaster can be had for less than $30.
Read more: 4 signs it’s time to replace your toaster oven
That’s why I decided to take a look at some of your less-expensive options to see if I could find a good value. I honed in on popular, well-reviewed models that cost between $50 and $100, and I used convection heating — a trick that uses a fan to circulate the hot air to evenly toast and cook — as a baseline, must-have feature.
Then, with six toaster ovens ready to go in our test kitchen, I set out to put them to the test to try to find the best of the lot. Of these six, we came away with a clear favorite, and we’re also including the aforementioned Panasonic and Breville toaster ovens because they remain well worth the splurge.
Other toaster ovens we tested
- Bialetti 35047: This countertop oven model was one of our top value picks of 2019 for its strong features and classy design. Unfortunately, it doesn’t seem to be available any longer, at least not at any of the online retailers we track. It isn’t even listed on the Bialetti website anymore.
- Black & Decker TO3265XSSD: One of the newest models from the top name in toaster ovens replaces the convection bake setting with a gimmicky, one-temperature-fits-all “Air Fry” mode. It’s fine for the price if you need a wide-bodied design with extra room for toast.
- Hamilton Beach 31123D: One of Hamilton Beach’s “Easy Reach” models, the slightly under-powered 31123D makes it a little easier to see inside as you’re cooking or broiling, thanks to a sloping “Easy Reach” door that lifts up to open. Too bad Hamilton Beach stamped a large logo on the glass to obstruct your view.
- Nostalgia Retro RTOV220RETRORED: The cheesy, retro-red design makes it look more like a toolbox than a toaster oven, and it felt a bit cheaply made. Still, this eye-catching model performed passably well in our tests.
- Toshiba AC25CEW-BS: The digital controls are nice to have in this fancy-looking, black stainless steel option, but it comes with a learning curve thanks to underpowered toasting and overpowered baking and broiling.
More from Chowhound: 10 toaster oven hacks you need to try right now
Bialetti 35047 | Black & Decker TO3265XSSD | Hamilton Beach 31123D | Nostalgia Retro RTOV220RETRORED | Oster TSSTTVCG05 | Toshiba AC25CEW-BS | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Energy Draw | 1,800W | 1,500W | 1,500W | 1,500W | 1,500W | 1,500W |
Settings | 9 (Toast, Bake, Broil, Warm, Bagel, Pizza, Cookies, Defrost, Reheat) | 4 (Toast, Bake, Broil, Air Fry) | 4 (Bake, Toast, Broil, Convection) | 4 (Bake, Pizza/Toast, Broil, Convection) | 5 (Bake, Toast, Broil, Warm, Turbo) | 10 (Bake, Toast, Broil, Convection, Pizza, Cookies, Rotisserie, Defrost, Reheat, Keep Warm) |
Toast time, 2 slices, medium setting | 5:00 | 4:00 | 3:30 | 5:30 | 4:30 | 3:20 |
Toast time, 2 slices, dark setting | 8:00 | 8:00 | 6:30 | 9:00 | 7:30 | 4:30 |
Exterior Dimensions | 19.7 x 15.8 x 14.2 in. | 21.5 x 23.0 x 11.2 in. | 9.4 x 18.7 x 15.2 in. | 19.2 x 15.4 x 10.8 in. | 18.5 x 15.7 x 10.4 in. | 19.0 x 10.8 x 15.6 in. |
Interior Width | 12 in. | 16 in. | 12 in. | 12.5 in. | 12 in. | 12.5 in. |
Interior Depth | 12 in. | 12 in. | 12 in. | 12 in. | 12 in. | 12 in. |
Interior Height (from bottom rack position) | 7.5 in. | 7.5 in. | 5 in. | 7 in. | 6 in. | 7 in. |
Broil Height (from top rack position) | 2.5 in. | 2 in. | 3.5 in. | 4 in. | 4 in. | 2 in. |
Weight | 18.0 lbs. | 19.0 lbs. | 14.0 lbs. | 15.6 lbs. | 14.9 lbs. | 16.2 lbs. |
Color | Black Stainless Steel | Stainless Steel | Stainless Steel | Red | Stainless Steel | Black Stainless Steel |
Key Features | “A Little Extra” button | Mesh air-frying rack | “Easy Reach” door | Retro design | None | Built-in rotisserie cooker |
Warranty | 1-year | 2-year | 1-year | 1-year | 1-year | 1-year |
Price | $90 | $79 | $69 | $99 | $64 | $99 |
What are my options?
You’ve got absolutely no shortage of toaster ovens to choose from. Names like Black & Decker, Hamilton Beach, Oster and countless others have been cranking the things out for generations now.
The true bargain-bin picks cost less than $50. If you’re willing to spend a little more, you should expect to get some form of convection heat and cooking, as well as perhaps a wider oven cavity, a few additional cooking preset options, digital controls, a non-stick coating on the bake pan or a nicer-looking design. The Bialetti and Toshiba models I tested come in black stainless steel, matching a modern large appliance trend, and the Toshiba model features a built-in rotisserie rack, too. The Nostalgia model offers a unique, red-bodied build, while lower-cost options from Hamilton Beach and Oster serve as simpler budget picks.
How we tested toaster ovens
Testing toaster ovens requires an awful lot of cooking, so I donned my trusty tan apron and got to work.
Specifically, I set out to cook a wide variety of common toaster oven fodder. With the exception of the toasting tests, where I looked at each toaster oven’s individual settings for light, medium and dark toast, I used standardized temperature and cook times, and followed the recommendations on the box for whatever I was cooking wherever possible.
More from Chowhound: How to Clean Your Toaster Oven
Pizza and other frozen snacks and foods
I also baked a bunch of frozen pizzas — personal-sized pepperoni pies from DiGiorno, to be specific. The box recommends baking a frozen pizza at 425 F for 17 minutes, so that’s what I did with each toaster oven.
The results were all over place, but not terribly surprising. The Hamilton Beach toaster oven was a little wimpy in the toast tests, and it followed suit here, too, with an underbaked pizza that needed another couple of minutes in the oven. Meanwhile, the toaster oven with the most power — the Bialetti — gave us burnt pizza that cooked a lot faster than you’d expect.
Toshiba burnt the pizza, too. That was more surprising since it had the opposite problem during my toast tests. Like Bialetti, it offers a dedicated pizza setting. With both models, the result was basically identical — burnt pizza when following the box instructions.
The best-cooked pizzas of the bunch came from Oster and Black & Decker, while the bright red, retro-designed Nostalgia toaster oven baked a passable pie, too.
In addition to DiGiorno’s, I made sure to test a number of other frozen snacks and foods, including mozzarella sticks (short bake time), Pizza Bagels (medium baking time) and waffle fries (long baking time). Again, for the most part, I was less concerned with how things tasted than I was with how much each toaster oven matched the recommended temperature and cook times compared with the user’s manual. The results largely lined up with what we saw from the pizza, but if you want to read more details, you can check out my full testing notes here.
- 6 Miami-based investors share their views on the region’s startup scene [TechCrunch]
- 10 PlayStation Announcements Loom In State Of Play Broadcast This Thursday [Game Informer]