How Does ‘Rings of Power’ Differ From Tolkien’s Works? A Full Breakdown By Episode – CNET [CNET]

There’s a fair bit of concern Amazon’s new TV series is going to drift heavily from the source material. We’re here to help analyze every episode.

Amazon’s new TV series The Rings of Power is a bit controversial for some. There are vocal groups concerned showrunners J.D. Payne and Patrick McKay won’t make every effort to ensure this show is in line with J.R.R. Tolkien’s collected works and may add things Tolkien wouldn’t approve of. For many Tolkien fans, this is a song we’ve heard before. There have been doubts cast on every modern Tolkien story brought to screen, including Peter Jackson’s The Lord of the Rings movies. 

While every episode of The Rings of Power is going to have a recap article courtesy of CNET’s own Erin Carson, this article will be dedicated entirely to the analysis of how well each episode sticks to what Tolkien wrote.

 To be clear, this analysis doesn’t include:

• Whether people of color should be on screen as dwarves, elves or Harfoots (they should, end of conversation).
• Whether dwarven women should have full beards (Tolkien was never clear on this, so I won’t be taking a position).
• Whether Tolkien is OK with people inventing things in his world (this letter from Tolkien to his publisher in 1951 makes his position clear).

Episode 1: Shadow of the Past

This episode broadly introduces the world, and a handful of the separate stories seemingly destined to intersect. Check out our full recap for more.

Finrod Felegund’s Dagger

In our opening scene, young Galadriel’s beautiful boat is destroyed, and her big brother stops her from beating the guilty party within an inch of his life for being such a tool. This scene is the first time we see Finrod’s dagger, which Galadriel takes as her own while she seeks out the enemy responsible for his death. 

Crossing the Sundering Seas

There’s nothing technically wrong about this scene. The elves left Valinor to wage a thousand years of war across much of Middle-earth, which led to Morgoth being stopped and Sauron going into a sort of hiding. 

But my goodness did this scene leave a lot out. There could’ve been an entire season of this show dedicated to just that handful of sentences, recapping how the elves found themselves in Middle-earth. If you’re curious, read the ninth chapter of the Quenta Silmarillion titled Of the Fight of the Ñoldor.

The village of Tirharad

If the name of this village didn’t sound familiar to you, you weren’t alone. Tolkien didn’t create Tirharad, but he didn’t create anything in this area that would later become Mordor. We know there were men living in what was then called the Southlands, because Tolkien wrote of how Shelob would prey upon men and elves before Sauron claimed the land as Mordor. 

The name Tirharad is a mashup of “watch” and “south” in Sindarin, which makes some sense given the way the village is essentially policed by the Silvan elves from their watchtower. This episode lays out how the descendants of men who served Morgoth settled in the surrounding area, and the elves keep a close eye on them out of concern that corruption may once again enter their hearts. We know that some men did serve Morgoth, whose fortress Udûn existed in the northeast part of the area that later became Mordor, so it isn’t a stretch that men would’ve settled here after the wars.

Galadriel’s return to Valinor

It’s long been suspected that Galadriel was either banned from returning to Valinor or didn’t believe she deserved to return to Valinor, due largely to this line in Galadriel’s Song of Eldamar:

What ship would bear me ever back across so wide a Sea?

This scene shows Galadriel being rewarded (sort of) with the ability to return home, along with the rest of her company. Though Tolkien did write that some elves were permitted to return home after the War of Wrath, it was never explicitly stated that Galadriel was among them. It was written that many high elves opted to remain in Middle-earth even as more of their kind returned home, and Galadriel’s activities at this time aren’t well documented, so this new story is filling in those gaps with new adventures of sorts.

Episode 2: Adrift

With a pair of mischievous Harfoots trying to care for The Stranger, Galadriel trying to swim across the Sundering Sea only to find several ways that can go wrong, Tirharad experiencing a pest control issue and Prince Durin having an axe to grind with Elrond, this is a busy episode. Check out the full recap here, and the lore analysis below. 

Nori’s not-so-hot foot

The Rite of Sigin-tarâg

Not a ton is known about what dwarves get up to in their halls under the mountains, because they don’t often invite people in who aren’t of their kin. The few exceptions in the Second Age are largely elves who worked closely with dwarven smiths to create a ton of different things, which we might get to see in this show but not in this episode. So, though Tolkien never wrote about Elrond claiming the Rite of Sigin-tarâg, there’s a ton of empty space when it comes to knowing what dwarves did in private. 

Sigin-tarâg doesn’t refer to some kind of competition. The word translates to longbeards, which is the other name for Durin’s folk or this particular kind of dwarf. In this context, the Rite of Sigin-tarâg is exactly as Durin explains it, a test of endurance his people created to settle internal disputes. It’s not something we’ve ever seen before, and not something we’d ever see in the Third Age because of what happens to Durin’s folk, so it’s plausible a challenge like this would exist. 

Disa’s resonance

As this isn’t a character created by Tolkien, there’s no record of the special way she helps dwarven miners do their thing. Dwarven women were kept from battle, and as a result aren’t really mentioned much at all in Tolkien’s works. But we do know that dwarves were said to be the best mining folk in the world because they were created with that purpose in mind. 

Tolkien never really expands on what specific abilities the dwarves have when it comes to mining, only that Aulë taught them special skills while creating the seven original dwarf lords. 

Orcs under the floorboards

There are many examples of Orcs tunneling in Middle-earth, and those tunnels typically lead to what Tolkien called Orc-holds. Some of these Orc-holds were small, like the ones seen in this episode, while others occupied entire mountains, like those seen in Mount Gundabad, which Orcs hold for most of the Second Age.

We know Tirharad isn’t a place Tolkien created, but its proximity to what would soon become Mordor makes it a perfect place for Orcs to be digging under.